Definition
Team Swachh's first idea was "an AI robot that cleans the whole town". Exciting, but is it the real problem? And could three students ever test it?
Identifying a real problem means finding a specific, evidenced need that affects real people, understanding its root cause, and describing it clearly in a problem statement, before thinking about technology. For the capstone, the problem should also be one where data and prediction could plausibly help, and one you can investigate yourself.
In simple words
Before a doctor treats you, they find out exactly what is wrong. Before you design an AI, you find out exactly what the problem is, who has it and why, by looking, asking and counting.
Why it matters
Most failed projects solve the wrong problem. Spending time here makes every later step easier and keeps your project useful to real people.
Key terms
- Observation
- Watching and recording what actually happens, with dates and details.
- Interview
- A planned conversation with someone affected, to learn about their experience.
- Evidence
- Facts, counts or quotes showing that a problem is real and how big it is.
- Root cause
- The underlying reason a problem happens.
- Scope
- The boundaries of a project: what it will and will not try to do.
- Problem statement
- One sentence naming who has the problem, what it is, where it happens and what an ideal solution would do.
Explained in detail
Gather evidence first
Team Swachh spent two weeks gathering evidence. Each morning on the way to school they recorded the state of six bins near the market: empty, half full, full or overflowing. They interviewed four shopkeepers, two residents and, with their teacher's help, a municipal sanitation supervisor. Their count showed that two of the six bins were overflowing on nine of the fourteen days, while the others were rarely more than half full. The supervisor explained that pickup trucks followed a fixed route on fixed days, with no way of knowing which bins were full.
Find the root cause
Asking "why" several times led the team from the symptom to the root cause. Why is there garbage on the street? Bins overflow. Why? Some bins fill much faster than others. Why are they not emptied? Trucks follow a fixed schedule. Why? The municipal team does not know which bins are full. That last answer is something information could fix, and it is far more specific than "the town is dirty". It also changed their idea: instead of a cleaning robot, they needed a way to tell the sanitation team which bins were full.
Team Swachh's 4Ws canvas
| W | Their answer |
|---|---|
| Who | Residents and shopkeepers near the market; the municipal sanitation team |
| What | Two of six bins overflowed on 9 of 14 days while others were rarely half full |
| Where | Six public bins around the main market, especially after weekly market days |
| Why | Less street litter, fewer animals eating plastic, less wasted truck time |
Their problem statement: "Residents and shopkeepers near our market have a problem that some public bins overflow for days while others are half empty, because the sanitation team cannot see which bins are full. An ideal solution would show the team, each morning, which bins need emptying."
Check the scope
- Is it specific enough to test in a few weeks?
- Do you have evidence, not just a feeling?
- Could data and prediction genuinely help, or would a simpler fix work better?
- Have you spoken to the people who have the problem?
Finally, check that you are allowed to investigate: ask a teacher before interviewing officials, and always explain to people why you are asking.
How it works
- Observe the problem and record evidence for at least a week.
- Interview at least three people affected.
- Ask "why" several times to find the root cause.
- Fill in the 4Ws canvas.
- Write your problem statement and check the scope.
Try it yourself
From robot to real problem
Team Swachh's first idea is a town-cleaning robot.
Evidence or assumption?
Sort each statement from a project journal.
The supervisor told us trucks follow a fixed weekly route
An app would definitely fix the problem
Bin 3 was overflowing on 9 of 14 mornings we checked
Everyone in town hates the bins
Four of five shopkeepers said smells were worst after market day
Common mistakes
- Starting from a cool technology instead of a real need.
- Relying on feelings instead of counted evidence.
- Choosing a problem too big to investigate.
Check yourself
Summary
- Gather evidence through observation and interviews before designing anything.
- Ask "why" to reach the root cause, then fill in the 4Ws.
- Write a specific, people-centred problem statement with a testable scope.
Finished reading?
Sources: CBSE Artificial Intelligence curriculum resources · Swachh Bharat Mission (Urban)