B5 · Generative AI and Conversational Assistants

Fact-Checking and Trusted Sources

Fact-checking is the practice of confirming a claim against reliable evidence before believing or sharing it. A trusted source is one with a record of accuracy, clear responsibility for what it publishes and a habit of correcting its mistakes.

8 min Beginner Jump to the activity

What you need: Nothing. This page starts from the beginning, with no programming and no formulas.

Definition

A message says a new law will cancel all bank accounts without a certain card. Your uncle has already forwarded it to forty people. How would you find out whether it is true?

Fact-checking is the practice of confirming a claim against reliable evidence before believing or sharing it. A trusted source is one with a record of accuracy, clear responsibility for what it publishes and a habit of correcting its mistakes.

In simple words

When a friend tells you the school will be closed tomorrow, you do not simply stay at home. You ask how they know, and you check the notice from the school. Fact-checking is that same instinct, used on purpose: where did this come from, and can I confirm it from somewhere I trust?

Why it matters

AI tools can produce fluent errors, and anyone can now publish anything. The ability to check a claim quickly has become a basic life skill, as necessary as reading. It protects you from being fooled, and it stops you from fooling others by passing on something false.

Key terms

Claim
A statement that something is true.
Evidence
Facts, records or data that support or contradict a claim.
Primary source
The original material: the law itself, the study itself, the official statistics, a recording of the speech.
Secondary source
A report or explanation about the original, such as a news article.
Lateral reading
Leaving a page to see what other reliable sources say about it and its author.
Reverse image search
Searching with a picture to find where else, and when, it has appeared.

Explained in detail

What professional fact-checkers do differently

In 2017 researchers at Stanford University gave the same task to three groups: university students, professors of history and professional fact-checkers. Each had to judge whether unfamiliar websites could be trusted. The students and the professors mostly stayed on the page. They read it carefully, looked at its design, checked its "About" section, and were often fooled by sites that looked respectable. The fact-checkers did something else. Within seconds they left the page, opened new tabs and searched for what other sources said about the organisation behind it. They were faster and far more accurate. The researchers called this lateral reading: reading across many sites, not down one.

Four moves: SIFT

A widely taught routine, devised by the educator Mike Caulfield, packs this into four moves that spell SIFT.

MoveWhat to doWhy
StopPause before you believe or share, especially if you feel angry, afraid or delightedFalse content is designed to make you react before you think
Investigate the sourceFind out who is behind it and what others say about themKnowing the source tells you how much weight to give it
Find better coverageSearch for the claim itself and see what reliable outlets reportIf it is true and important, others will have reported it
Trace to the originalFollow quotes, statistics and pictures back to where they first appearedThings are often cut, cropped or taken out of context

What makes a source worth trusting

  • It says who wrote it and who is responsible for it.
  • It shows where its information comes from, so that you can check.
  • It carries a date, and the date fits the claim.
  • It corrects its mistakes openly.
  • It has expertise in the subject: a health agency on health, a statistics office on numbers.
  • It does not gain directly from your believing the claim.

No source is perfect, and trusted does not mean always right. It means that the source has methods for getting things right and takes responsibility when it gets them wrong. An anonymous forwarded message has neither.

Go to the origin where you can

For many claims you can reach the primary source directly. If a message describes a new government rule, the rule itself will be on an official government website. If an article quotes a study, the study has a title you can search for. If a statistic is quoted, the office that collects it will have published it. In India the government's Press Information Bureau runs a fact-check unit that addresses false claims about government schemes and rules, and several independent fact-checking organisations publish their findings and their methods.

Checking an AI answer

  1. Pick out the claims that matter: names, dates, numbers, quotations, anything you will rely on.
  2. For each one, search in a separate tab for an independent source.
  3. If the tool gave a source, open it. Confirm that it exists and that it actually says what the tool reported.
  4. If two reliable, independent sources agree, you can be reasonably confident. If you cannot confirm it, do not use it.

Two sources count as independent only if neither copied the other. Ten websites repeating the same press release are one source, not ten.

How it works

Type of claimGood place to check
A government rule or schemeThe ministry's own website; the official fact-check unit
A health claimA health ministry, a recognised medical body, a doctor
A statisticThe organisation that collected the data
A quotationA recording or the published text of the speech
A photo of an eventReverse image search to see when it first appeared
A scientific findingThe published study, or a science outlet that links to it

Worked example

Two notices about the same event are pinned on the board. The old notice, dated 2 March, says: 'The science fair will be held on 14 March in the main hall at 10 am.' The new notice, dated 9 March, says: 'Change of date: the science fair will now be held on 21 March in the library hall at 10 am.' A learner asks two AI tools and gets two different answers. Answer A: '14 March, in the main hall.' Answer B: '21 March, in the library hall.'

To decide, go to the original source, the school's own notice board or website, not a third AI. Compare the dates on the notices: 9 March is later than 2 March, so the new notice replaces the old one. Then find the exact line: 'will now be held on 21 March in the library hall'. Answer B matches the latest original notice; answer A was built from the outdated one. The habit to keep is: original source, latest date, exact line.

Try it yourself

Checking a forwarded message

A message says: "From Monday, every phone without the new update will be blocked. Forward to all!"

Put the SIFT moves in order

Which comes first, and which last?

  1. 1Investigate who is behind the claim
  2. 2Find what other reliable sources report
  3. 3Trace the claim back to its original context
  4. 4Stop before reacting or sharing

Check three AI claims

Do this with an adult if you are using a chat assistant.

  1. Ask a chat assistant for three facts about your own town or district, with numbers if possible.
  2. Write each fact on a separate line.
  3. Check each one against an independent source: an official website, a textbook or a knowledgeable adult.
  4. Mark each as confirmed, wrong or could not confirm.

Think about it

  • How many of the three could you confirm?
  • Which was hardest to check, and why?

Which evidence settles it?

Two AI answers disagree about the science fair. Sort each piece of evidence.

  • An AI answer that sounds very sure

  • A forwarded screenshot with no date

  • Which AI answer is longer

  • The latest notice on the school's own website, with its date

  • The exact line 'will now be held on 21 March'

  • The school office confirming the new date

A new case: when does school reopen?

Settle a disagreement between two AI answers.

  1. One AI tool says school reopens after the holidays on 3 June; another says 10 June.
  2. Find the original notice from the school and write down its date.
  3. Copy the exact line that gives the reopening date.
  4. Decide which answer is right, and explain why the other might be wrong.

Think about it

  • What would you do if you found two official notices with different reopening dates?

Common mistakes

  • Judging a website by how professional it looks. Design is cheap; reputation is earned.
  • Counting many copies of the same claim as many sources.
  • Sharing first and checking later.

Check yourself

Question 1

1. What is lateral reading?

Question 2

2. Which is a primary source for a new government rule?

Question 3

3. Ten websites repeat the same unverified claim, word for word. How many independent sources is that?

Summary

  • Fact-checking means confirming a claim with reliable evidence before believing or sharing it.
  • Use SIFT: stop, investigate the source, find better coverage, trace to the original.
  • Check AI answers claim by claim, using sources that are independent of the tool and of each other.

Finished reading?

Sources: The SIFT method for checking information (Mike Caulfield) · Civic Online Reasoning (Digital Inquiry Group)